Job search · updated November 2026
How to spot a ghost job before you apply
By Safad, the studio that makes Applylane
A ghost job is a posting for a job nobody is really hiring for. It might have been filled months ago, or kept up to collect resumes. Here are the signs, how to check a job in a few minutes, and what to do if you think you've already applied to one.
- Of jobs posted on Greenhouse in a quarter are ghost jobs[source]
- 18–22%
- Of hiring managers said their company posted a fake job in the past year[source]
- 40%
- Of job seekers have seen a posting they suspected had no real opening[source]
- 86%
- US hires per job posting in 2023, down from 0.75 in 2018[source]
- Under 0.5
The signs
Seven signs a job isn't really open
It's been up for months
In February 2026, about 14% of Indeed listings had been up for 30 days or more, and 4% for four months or more [source]. An old posting isn't always a ghost, but it's worth checking before you spend an hour on it.
It keeps coming back
The same job, reposted every few weeks, or back a week after you were turned down. A fresh date can mislead: LinkedIn treats a reposted job as a new one [source].
It isn't on the company's own site
Most employers list their real openings on their own careers page. If the job is only on job boards, and the company's site doesn't mention it, be wary [source].
The description could be any job
No team, no manager, no real responsibilities, nothing you couldn't paste into another posting. Indeed's own advice is to look for a detailed, role-specific description [source].
It's always open
“Always accepting applications” or “join our talent community”. Half of hiring managers in one survey kept postings up because they're always open to new people [source]. That's a resume pool, not a role.
The company is cutting, not hiring
A hiring freeze or layoffs in the news, and the posting still up. Plans change after a job is posted, and postings don't always come down.
Nobody can tell you about it
The recruiter can't say who the hiring manager is or when they want someone to start. Asking the company directly is one of the best checks [source].
One sign on its own proves little. Two or three together, and it's worth asking before you apply.
Before you apply
How to check a job in five minutes
Find it on the company's careers page
If it's there, apply there. If it isn't, ask before you put in the work.
Skim the news
Search the company's name with “layoffs” or “hiring freeze”. Two minutes can save an evening.
Ask one question
A short note to the recruiter: “Is this role still open, and when are you hoping someone starts?” A real opening gets a real answer.
Keep a copy of the posting
Postings get edited, reposted and taken down. With your own copy you can tell whether it's the same job back again, and you can still read it before an interview.
Why it happens
Why companies post jobs they won't fill
In Resume Builder's 2024 survey, hiring managers who had posted a fake job said they did it to look open to outside talent (67%), to look like the company is growing (66%), to make staff think help was coming (63%) and to collect resumes for later (59%) [source].
Some ghosts aren't on purpose. Plans change after a job is posted, and job boards can keep showing copies of listings the employer already took down [source]. Either way, the cost lands on you: the time spent applying, and the wait for a reply that won't come.
The law
Are ghost jobs illegal?
Ontario: in force
Since 1 January 2026, employers with 25 or more employees must say in a public job posting whether it's for an existing vacancy. They must also tell people they interviewed whether a decision was made, within 45 days [source].
Already applied?
If you think you applied to a ghost job
- Don't wait on it. Keep applying elsewhere. One posting shouldn't pause your search.
- Follow up once after about two weeks. Here are follow-up templates to copy.
- Count it as a no after a month of silence. Here's how long hiring usually takes.
- Report it to the job board if it's clearly not real.
Keep a copy of every job you apply to
Save a job with Applylane's browser extension, or paste its link, and the job description is kept on its card. If the posting comes back, you can compare. If it's taken down, you can still read it.
Applications with no reply for two weeks show up in Needs attention, and Insights shows your ghosted rate: how many got no reply at all after 30 days. Free, with no cap on applications.
Questions
Good to know.
What is a ghost job?
A posting for a job the company isn't really trying to fill. It may have been left up after the job was filled, kept up to collect resumes or to look like the company is growing, or posted when someone inside was already picked. It isn't a scam: a ghost job comes from a real employer, while a job scam is a fake employer after your money or personal details.
How common are ghost jobs?
Common enough to plan for. Greenhouse classified 18 to 22% of the jobs posted on its platform as ghost jobs in any given quarter, and 40% of hiring managers in a 2024 Resume Builder survey said their company had posted a fake job in the past year. There's no official count.
Are ghost jobs illegal?
Mostly not. Ontario is the exception: since 1 January 2026, employers there with 25 or more employees must say in a public posting whether it's for an existing vacancy. New York's legislature passed a similar bill in 2026, but it isn't law yet. There's no US federal law against them.
How long is too long for a job posting to be up?
There's no fixed line, but hiring usually takes about 5 to 9 weeks from posting to accepted offer. A posting that's been up for several months, or reposted again and again, deserves a check before you spend time on it. On LinkedIn, posts close on their own after six months unless the employer closes them sooner. Free Indeed posts stop showing after 30 days, but paid ones can run on.
Should I still apply if I think it's a ghost job?
If applying takes two minutes, it costs little to try. If it means an hour of tailoring, check first: find the job on the company's site, or ask the recruiter whether it's still open. If you apply and hear nothing, follow up once after two weeks, then move on.
Keep reading
Related guides
Sources
Where the facts come from
- Greenhouse, 2024 State of Job Hunting Report (Dec 2024)
- Resume Builder, survey of 649 US hiring managers (Jun 2024)
- Resume Builder, survey of 1,011 US job seekers (Oct 2026)
- Revelio Labs, Ghost job postings (Oct 2023)
- Clarify Capital, 176,268 Indeed listings (Feb 2026)
- Clarify Capital, survey of 1,045 hiring managers (Sep 2022)
- Congressional Research Service, Ghost Job Postings, IF12977 (Apr 2025)
- Ontario, Your guide to the Employment Standards Act: publicly advertised job postings
- New York State Assembly, bill S8877 and its history
- New Jersey Legislature, bill S2136 history
- LinkedIn Help, Repost a job
- LinkedIn Help, When job posts close
- LinkedIn Help, Job search filters
- Indeed Help, Improving your job searches
- Indeed, Ghost jobs explained (May 2026)
- Indeed for employers, Free vs sponsored jobs (May 2026)
- Fortune, How to spot ghost job listings (Jan 2025)
Surveys measure different things: Greenhouse classified postings on its own platform, Resume Builder asked hiring managers and job seekers, and Revelio Labs matched postings to hires. Laws and bills checked 12 November 2026.